Jump to content
Absomphe

Your Top Ten Commercial Absinthes

Recommended Posts

I enjoy Mystique, but am surprised that it made it that high on Abby's list. I also think that if I do a side by side comparison of my top 10, it would probably score higher than 9. So, I guess for me it falls somewhere between 2 and 9.

 

Regardless, the standards for absinthe nowadays has gotten so high, that I think the top ten are so close, that they could even change places just based on individual batches.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My top 4 is undoubtedly:

 

1. Belle Amie

 

2. Jade Nouvelle-Orleans

 

T3. 1797 Roquette

 

T3. Marteau

 

I thought I preferred the Marteau, then I had another glass of 1797 and thought "no, I like this better"... until my next glass of Marteau. I decided ultimately that I preferred which ever one I was drinking at that moment.

 

After that it's a crap-shoot, and it's been so long since I've had a few that I don't think I could list them accurately. The Blanchette may just creep in there at #5.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1: Ike 68

2: PF 1901

3: Verte Suisse

4: Duplais Blanche

5: Duplais Verte

6: Helfrich

7: Duplais Balance

8: NO

9: Eddie

10: Kübler 53

 

It looks like I should find some Bel Amie and Marteau

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1) Doubs Mystique

2) PF 1901

3) Roquette 1797

4) Absinthe Nouvelle-Orléans

5) Absinthe Edouard

6) Duplais Balance

7) Absinthe Helfrich

8) Blanchette

9) Blanche Traditionelle (brut d'alambic)

10) Eichelberger

 

Not the easiest to compile a list like this. Some rankings in the top area are somewhat interchangeable, I think.

And there are still a couple of quality absinthes that I haven't tried yet, that I'm sure would rank very high too.

 

The Jades have got some serious competition in the new brands from Les fils d'Emile Pernot – I was really floored when I first tasted the Doubs Mystique! I must lift my hat. The anise has a quality which I must say is the closest to [a particular] pre-ban I've experienced this far, and that goes for Roquette as well. I'm not saying it is exactly the same, but my nose detects that highly appreciated, characteristic butterscotch aroma in the smell in both of them. That particular nuance is lacking in the Jades, however well-crafted and harmoniously balanced I really consider them when it comes to other qualities on the whole.

It's great to see the development of modern absinthes these days!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I was really floored when I first tasted the Doubs Mystique! I must lift my hat. The anise has a quality which I must say is the closest to [a particular] pre-ban I've experienced.

 

To me, all of the herbs in the Mystique smack of really high quality, and the overall impression I get is of a Besançon style, but with an overlayed tonic-like quality.

 

When I first tasted it, I was also floored, but my second tasting left me craving more from the other herbs supporting that marvelous wormwood. However, upon revisiting it a few more times, I find those herbs are more bright than I thought, and the mouthfeel, which I had felt was a bit thin, is actually ideal for this absinthe, and, while not approaching the 1901, has its own kind of luxuriousness.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I definitely undertand that I am in the minority on this but...

 

I think the louche is too weak and the mouthfeel is anything but ideal.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

And what is your opinion of the Roquette's louche?

 

I'm curious, because you commented on the Roquette not having the "muskiness" of the Doubs, and I got the feeling it appealed to you more all around.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I think the louche is too weak and the mouthfeel is anything but ideal.

Those are not qualities that would hurt my opinion all that much if the absinthe is otherwise fantastic.

 

I need to revisit Mr.Defo's bottle of Doubs Mystique now that it's been open for a while. Last I tried it was the day he opened it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I do like the Roquette much better but the louche and mouth feel are not good, definitely worse than the Mystique.

 

As my preferences go a thick mouthfeel and louche are very important to making an absinthe that I will like.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
To me, all of the herbs in the Mystique smack of really high quality, and the overall impression I get is of a Besançon style
Agreed. The wormwood is just excellent.

 

As for the louche, the Roquette has a thin louche, yes. Yet, with ice-water and a really slow drip it's not Un Emile thin, though; I have no problem with it. Like peridot pointed out – in this case there are indeed other qualities that makes it fantastic. I'm not going to say despite the thin louch, since I don't think a good absinthe must necessarily have this super dense, opaque louche to get the best marks. And mouthfeel is not automatically associated with the louche either, in all cases.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I don't think a good absinthe must necessarily have this super dense, opaque louche to get the best marks. And mouthfeel is not automatically associated with the louche either, in all cases.

 

Agreed, and agreed.

 

The Edouard Pernod I sampled didn't really have such a thick, and opaque louche, (although it was spetacular in the formation aspect) but if you tasted it blindfolded, you couldn't tell that from the mouthfeel, which was decadent.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Considering I've only had 11 brands of absinthe (not including the 3 "czechsinths" from my less informed intro) this shouldn't be too hard to list my top 10 thus far.

 

1. Duplais Balance

2. Jade Edouard

3. Jade New Orleans

4. Duplais Verte

5. Eichelberger

6. Jade Verte Suisse

7. Kübler 53

9. Verte de Fougerolles

10. Mansinthe

 

The 11th was Clandestine la Bleu, but I didn't care too much for it.

I'm sure I'll be adding Lucid and St George soon enough, and perhaps even another "czechsinth"; my friend bought a bottle of Hill's for 10 bucks in a train station when she was in the Czech Republic.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

What train station? That sounds way too cheap, especially with the current exchange rate (the Czech Crown is out-pacing the Euro). Not that I'm in the market or anything, but even here Hill's is among the more expensive oil-mixes.

 

Now, I guess I need to take a crack at this exercise, even though it's first thing in the morning and my head's not really oriented towards 10 different absinthes at this hour (I know, what the hell's amatter with me?).

 

1. Belle Ami

2. Nouvelle Orleans

3. Blanchette

4. Verte Suisse

5. Helfrich

6. Eichelberger

7. Eduard

8. Twin Tech

9. Duplais Verte

10. ClB

 

But don't hold me to it. It's fluid, you know.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1. absinthe noël 2007 (although it was a ltd. edition, so I'm not sure if that's okay for the list, it is, however, still commercially available at Matter-Luginbühl's)

2. PF 1901

3. Edouard

4. Duplais Verte

5. Duplais Balance

6. Brevans

7. Mansinthe

8. Eichelberger

9. Nouvelle Orléans

10. Marteau

Edited by fryke

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
What train station? That sounds way too cheap, especially with the current exchange rate (the Czech Crown is out-pacing the Euro). Not that I'm in the market or anything, but even here Hill's is among the more expensive oil-mixes.

 

Are you sure? I just went to xe.com and was informed that $10 is equal to 177 czech koruny (crowns). Regardless, I cringed when she told me she picked up a bottle of absinthe while over there. My suspisions were validated when she showed me the small bottle of Hill's. It really does look like mouthwash.

 

I really should try it though, if only to see what all the :puke: is about.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
My suspisions were validated when she showed me the small bottle of Hill's. It really does look like mouthwash.

 

I really should try it though, if only to see what all the [nausea] is about.

Yeah, I guess, maybe a small sample bottle might go for that. I was thinking bigger. Anyway, you should try it. There's far, far, faaaar worse out there. You'll appreciate some of the wider discussion of assbinth if you've actually tasted one of the less of the leastest.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Woah, tough calls...

 

Jade Nouvelle Orleans

Doub's Mystique

La P'Tite <-- so underrated!!!

Jade Verte Suisse

Jade Edouard

[hg]

Roquette 1797

Marteau

Jade PF1901

Belle Amie

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm not sure I could come up with 10. I mean, I know I have had way more then 10, but it has been so long since I have had more then 3-4 commercials, I'd be a biased and inaccurate judge.

 

My 4 favs though?

 

CLB

PF 1901

NO

Eich

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Considering I've only had 11 brands of absinthe (not including the 3 "czechsinths" from my less informed intro) this shouldn't be too hard to list my top 10 thus far.

 

1. Duplais Balance

2. Jade Edouard

3. Jade New Orleans

4. Duplais Verte

 

I've noticed that you have a special affinity for Duplais Balance, I have read past posts of yours and that you have spoken highly of it consistently. The reason I bring this up is because Balance was my first Absinthe, my first purchased and first tasted. :cheers: Grate minds think alike!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

For the benefit of anyone hoping to draw some conclusions from this thread -

 

It took about 5 minutes to add up the lists. I gave 3 pts for every 1st place pick, 2 pts for every 2nd place, and 1 pt for being in somebody's top 3 list, and this is the "forum-wide top list" I came up with -

 

1. Jade PF 1901

2. Belle Amie

3. Jade Edouard

4. Doubs Mystique

5. Jade Nouvelle-Orleans

6. Duplais Balance

7. Roquette 1797

 

6 out of the top 7 come from just two distilleries - Combier/Jade Liqueurs (Saumur) and Pernot (Pontarlier)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Nice work. I wonder how this would compare with similar polls we've done in the past. Will Balance or Roquette 1797 be in that list in a year? I'm not casting aspersions at either (I like Balance and haven't tried Roquette 1797) but suggesting there could be other factors skewing your results. New kids are frequently popular and haven't stood the test of time. Balance is a good absinthe but much more affordable so it has probably been sampled by many more members than say the Jade Verte Suisse. I'm guessing here but I wonder how much your list would have changed if you had included the top 5 in point gathering instead of just the top three? Or hell, awarded points for anything in the top ten?

 

One other minor point, I think the numbers are a little screwy since your award system makes the number one three-times better (point-wise) than the number three. I suspect most of us labored over what went into the top three and none of us (I'm speculating) would say our top pick was three times better than our third pick.

 

Nice work and it's interesting but potentially misleading.

 

Now, can I encourage you to head over to the Newcomer section and introduce yourself to everyone? :cheers:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Kinda of my point, Dakini. A very quick scan of everyone that picked ten, I counted 12 out of 16 that put Eich on their list. Z_for_Zendetta's work is interesting but it leaves too much out to be definitive.

 

Remember: Eich is good and it's good for you! :cheers:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Please sign in to comment

You will be able to leave a comment after signing in



Sign In Now

×